Official government website of the Government of Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
Link to official Saudi websites end with edu.sa

All links to official educational websites in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia end with sch.sa or edu.sa

Government websites use the HTTPS protocol for encryption and security.

Secure websites in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia use the HTTPS protocol for encryption.

Registered with the Digital Government Authority under number:

20260803330
View Article

Mechanisms of Uṣūlī Reasoning and Their Role in Shaping a Methodologically Disciplined Juristic Intellect: An Analytical Study

Issue 106, Page 68-88

TEXT


Abstract

This study examines mechanisms of uṣūlī reasoning and their contribution to a methodologically disciplined juristic intellect. It addresses a gap in contemporary studies that affirm Islamic legal theory’s role in regulating reasoning without adequately analysing its mechanisms. It clarifies these concepts and examines how practice cultivates competence according to practitioners’ preparation and expertise. Using an inductive and analytical approach, it examines selected mechanisms concerning textual interpretation, analogy and legal causation, objections, evidentiary conflict and preponderance, ascertaining rulings’ factual applicability (taḥqīq al-manāṭ), and Sharīʿa objectives and consequences. Their structure and operating conditions are analysed across four interrelated levels: conceptual and interpretive precision, argument construction and legal causation, assessment of evidence and arguments, and legal application. The study identifies methodological competence as an acquired capacity developed through repeated sound reasoning. Ruling derivation and competence development are two aspects of the same practice, which does not necessarily qualify learners for ijtihād or independent fatwa issuance. Sound argumentation requires delimiting disputed issues, observing evidentiary hierarchies, examining causal attributes, testing whether evidence establishes claims, evaluating counterarguments, and considering reconciliation before determining preponderance. Sound evidence and interpretation do not ensure valid application: this requires verifying the grounds for applying a ruling, fulfilling conditions, establishing the absence of impediments, considering consequences, and accounting for particular cases and universal principles. The study recommends improved instruction, graduated exercises, and applied studies assessing the soundness of contemporary legal reasoning.


Corresponding author

Abdulsateer Mohammad Wali

Assistant Professor ، جامعة الجوف ، Hollow


About the Article

Article Type

Original Article

Language

Arabic

Receive Date

10 May 2026

Review Date

12 Jul 2026

Accept Date

19 Jul 2026

Open Access

Yes

Copyright License

حقوق النشر(c) 2026. هذا العمل مرخص بموجب ترخيصCreative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC)

أستاذ

أ.د. عبدالله بن حسين العمودي

Show All Editors

Downloads Count

44

Magazine Info

ISSN: 1658-8738