Umm Al-Qura University

Umm Al-Qura University

Educational Journal Peer-reviewing Form

 Peer Review    From : - 2018/01/16 م , To : - 2020/11/10 م

There is a saved copy of this form. Do not forget to submit the form after completing all the required fields to reset the saved form. Click here

User Details :

Following Data will be included with the From

    Additional Information of Peer-Reviewer

    * Address:

    * Academic rank

    * Year of obtaining the academic rank

    * General major

    * Specific major

    * Research interest

    * Areas you prefer to peer review

    * Mobile phone

    Bank Account Information

    * Bank account number (IBAN) or swift code

    * I undertake that all bank information is correct.

    * Bank name

    * Country and city

    Title of Scientific Material

    * Title of the peer-reviewed research

    * Research Field

    Section 1: Aspects of Scientific Research

    First: Research Topic

    * 1- The research topic is suitable to its field.

    * 2- The research title is suitable to its content.

    * 3- The research problem is clear and specific.

    * 4- The importance of the research in theory and practice.

    * 5- The objectives and importance of the research are clear.

    * 6- Relevance of the objectives of the study to the research topic.

    * 7- Scientific contribution made by the research to its field.

    * 8- Coherence between research topics and paragraphs.

    * 9- The researcher’s adherence to the objectives of the research.

    Second: Theoretical Framework and Previous Studies

    * 1- The theoretical framework of the research is comprehensive and clear.

    * 2- The research is characterized by profound theoretical analysis.

    * 3- There is a logical and proper link between the theoretical framework and the research topic.

    * 4- Proper, logical ordering of theoretical perceptions and concepts.

    * 5- Relevance of the previous studies referenced in the research.

    * 6- Comprehensiveness of the previous studies referred to in the research.

    * 7- The researcher's accuracy in terms of documenting the information used in the research.

    * 8- The researcher’s accurate citation of the information used in the research.

    * 9- The information and scientific facts included in the research are modern.

    Third: Research Methodology

    * 1- The relevance of the used methodology to the problem of the research.

    * 2- The methodology’s correlation with the theoretical framework of the research topic.

    * 3- Soundness of the scientific formulation of the research hypotheses and enquiries.

    * 4- The research hypotheses and inquiries are in line with the objectives of the research.

    * 5- Clarity and precision of the independent and dependent variables in the research.

    * 6- Adopting a proper method for selecting a sample from the original community.

    * 7- The selected sample represents the original community.

    * 8- Proper research application procedures.

    * 9- The research tools used for collecting data are appropriate.

    * 10- The data collection tools are credible.

    * 11- Stability of data collection tools.

    * 12- The use of sound language and style in the research, in general.

    Fourth: Statistical Analysis Tools

    * 1- The suitability of the statistical style for the data of the research.

    * 2- The validity of data and statistical tables.

    * 3- Accurate use of the statistical style in analysis.

    Fifth: Research Findings

    * 1- The researcher's achievement of the desired results from the research.

    * 2- Importance of the results reached by the researcher.

    * 3- The researcher’s ability to link the research results to each other.

    * 4- The researcher’s ability to analyze and explain the results.

    * 6- Accuracy in linking the results to the theoretical framework and similar studies

    * 6- Reality of the recommendations reached by the researcher.

    * 7- Relevance of the recommendations to the research results.

    * 8- The researcher's accurate use of references in the research body and proper arrangement of the reference list.

    Section 2: General Remarks

     All the following remarks shall be sent to be reviewed by the researcher.

    * First: Judging the eligibility of the research for publication, as follows

    * Second: Notes about which no question has been raised in any research fields should be written. In addition, the reasons for the judgement should be clearly stated, and the required amendments should be stated in points. Amendments for consideration (if any) should be also stated.
    Allowed extensions : mp3, wav, wma, mp4, wmv, avi, flv, gif, jpg, jpeg, png, 7z, csv, doc, docx, gz, gzip, pdf, ppt, pptx, ppsx, txt, xls, xlsx, zip
    Allowed Size : 10000

     Third: The research after peer-reviewing
    Allowed extensions : mp3, wav, wma, mp4, wmv, avi, flv, gif, jpg, jpeg, png, 7z, csv, doc, docx, gz, gzip, pdf, ppt, pptx, ppsx, txt, xls, xlsx, zip
    Allowed Size : 10000

     Other Attachments
    Allowed extensions : mp3, wav, wma, mp4, wmv, avi, flv, gif, jpg, jpeg, png, 7z, csv, doc, docx, gz, gzip, pdf, ppt, pptx, ppsx, txt, xls, xlsx, zip
    Allowed Size : 10000


    CAPTCHA Image




    Loading